Home > Music > Your Feedback
Your Feedback
Comments? Concerns? Questions? We'd love to hear from you: Music@ChristianityToday.com
A Rush of Enthusiasm
Posted 09/10/07
Thanks for your review of Rush's new album from a Christian perspective. I've been an on-again-off-again Rush fan for 30 years. As a Christian that whole time, I've lamented Peart's clear declarations of unbelief over the years, going all the way back to the song "Free Will" from the 1980s. It's always been sad to me, because Peart is obviously an unusually sensitive soul. He discerns an awful lot of truth in life, and yet never seems to see The Truth. As I'm sure many music fans often do, I've sometimes wished I could sit down with him a while and talk about matters of faith. But alas, he's probably heard it all before, or at least thinks he has. I just wonder if he's ever personally known any truly thinking Christians. I will continue to pray for Neil Peart.
Morgan Trotter
Posted 09/10/07
Excellent piece! Thoughtful, intelligent, well written and not condescending. Well done.
Frank King
Recommendations to Rethink Reviews
Posted 09/10/07
I feel your comments concerning Casting Crowns' The Altar and The Door and Hillsong's Saviour King are very harsh and critical. Based on your reviews I would neither buy nor withhold from buying Christian CDs. I wish I knew what you based your reviews on—it seems that whoever reviews CDs does not seem to like either of the abovementioned artists and that's a pity. I and many others feel very blessed when listening to these albums. These are artists that hear from God and record accordingly. If the truth be known, there seems to be very little difference between Christian reviews and secular reviews—altogether too harsh and not fair to either the readers or to the artists. How about positive reviews and changing who reviews CDs?
Ann Reeson
Posted 09/10/07
We were surprised reading the article about the last Hillsong album in your website. It is written in a negative perspective and it shows the subjective opinion of the author. A serious [publication] like you cannot afford to publish such articles, which aim to form a certain impression in the reader, rather than offering an objective review that lets readers make their own conclusions. These articles look unprofessional and are not in the spirit of Christian ethics.
Tsvetomir Genchev
Posted 09/10/07
Concerning your review of Lindsey Kane's Move Me Aside, it is very disappointing that the Christian music industry acts no different than the mainstream industry. When did we become so high and mighty to judge someone on what God has blessed? I'm appalled that your web site wrote something so scathing about a girl who has God's anointing on her. Why are you trying to shoot down what chance she has? For your information, underground music generally has a better following. If you want to put her back there, by all means please do so. God will still use her immensely.
Emily Marie
Crowning Casting's Achievements
posted 09/04/07
I read your review of Casting Crowns' new CD and was shocked by how hard and unfair you were. I went to their release party last night and it blew me away. It was not a thrown together album as you implied. It was thought provoking and people can really identify with the meaning of the songs. Unfortunately, too many artists sing what people want to hear instead of getting to the nuts and bolts of life. Mark Hall listens to what God is telling him! Maybe if you had been there last night your critique would not have been so harsh! Everyone in the band is so genuine and they totally walk the talk. You never mentioned the bonus track on the CD. Mark and Megan sing a song in Korean which will give you goose bumps. You wait: this album will go platinum as well!
Kara Rebitch
posted 09/04/07
You're right: I am one of those hardcore fans you mentioned, and I completely support this album. Maybe they were doing something different this time; maybe it wasn't about the ones who already listen and love their music, but rather the ones who don't listen or have never heard—the ones who need a certain word or chord that stands out and catches their attention. Not to say that the previous ones didn't, but God is constantly challenging us and molding us so that we may become who he wants us to be. Who are we to say, "No, we prefer it this way." Step outside the box and see the big picture! It isn't about what you think it should be, it is about how God wants it to be.
Maranda Edgar
Defending Discernment
posted 09/04/07
I'm e-mailing you specifically because of Russ Breimeier's commentary "Defining? Or Descerning?" I work as a music department head in a prominent Christian bookstore from Saskatoon, Canada. I constantly get presented with the argument of "Christian music"—what it is and what it means. So when I saw the commentary, I was greatly moved and fully appreciative. I not only completely agree with what Russ had to say, but it's caused me to use this commentary as an in-store tool/resource in determining what [music to bring into the store]—it's already inspired some great questions and responses here. The debate about so-called "Christian music" will never end and will never stop bugging me. Thank you for a great resource and an amazing commentary on an issue that will [unfortunately] always be point of division in Christendom.
Luke Johnson
Hallelujahs for Head's Testimony
posted 08/20/07
I am so inspired by the story of Brian "Head" Welch. I am a 27-year-old male who has also fallen victim to the nothingness of meth. And I have a beautiful 4-year-old daughter who I am now fighting to get back due to circumstances following that addiction. I've got to say it's not easy, but I know that Light will shine, and I know the fight is well worth the prize. Thank you, Mr. Welch, for being a role model for us dads that choose the wrong road. I hope and pray to be with my daughter soon, and as happy as you look with yours.
Andy Telles
posted 08/20/07
I think you did an awesome job with the Brian 'Head' Welch interview! These are the kind of interviews today's youth needs to read and hear about. He got to a point where no one could do anything to help him, but God was knocking on his heart's door as the only answer. I believe God will use him mightily in the music business to touch other musicians who are dangling at the end of their ropes and have nowhere or no one to turn to, except God.
Loretta Partida
posted 08/20/07
I am so encouraged by this article. My grandson is a Korn fan, much to my dismay. I purchased the book for him, and I think the Lord will use this to bring him back to the Lord. Thank you so much.
Carolyn Scroppo
posted 08/20/07
Thanks be to God for you and your witness, Christian Music Today! I love how you are able to accept Christians with tattoos, foul language, long hair, whatever. Too often we spoil our chance to witness by judging.
Vicky Yant
Taking Issue
posted 08/20/07
I attend Maranatha church where Joann Rosario's father Nahum Rosario pastors. Joann is a beautiful woman of God with a beautiful voice that God has blessed her with. I believe that a CD shouldn't focus on the voice, but should focus on the message. Jesus didn't win souls by singing; he won them through his message. You may think that Joann's full potential wasn't administered in her Joyous Salvation CD, but I believe it was because she put her heart in it. The messages in her song have you wanna fall in love with Christ all over again. Even though to your knowledge she didn't "sing to her full potential," at least people's lives are being changed and won over by Christ.
Jacqueline Bonfante
posted 08/20/07
Reviews like the one for Mark Roach's Every Reason Why make me question what the point is of such negativity and microscopic scrutiny. I personally felt there is such a negative vibe to this review that the unwritten subtitle might as well have been, "You're an idiot if you like this album." Well color me stupid then. When it comes to worship music, I listen to the music through the lens of, "Could we do this as a church, and would our people track with this?" The answer is yes to all these questions for many of the songs on Mark's album. I'm sure if the reviewer was looking through the lens of quality for any new Christian music CD, he'd be right on the mark. But again, I feel there's too much subjectivity to what makes a worship album "good" to be so merciless in a review.
Carl C. Kremer
Taking Inspiraiton
posted 08/20/07
I'm the Fine Arts director at my local church and I just came back from a week in Indianapolis, Indiana where 12,000 students competed in a National Fine Arts competition, and I would bet money that all 12,000 students just became new fans of Group 1 Crew. They were beyond amazing. I love it when a band can live up to it's hype and acclaim. The CD is amazing but they just kill it live! Thanks for sparking interest with your review.
Esperanza Canales
Regarding Sinéad …
Editor's note: We're receiving a number of e-mails in response to our interview with Sinéad O'Connor, who has, shall we say, some "unconventional theological understandings." Or, perhaps more accurately, misunderstandings …
posted 07/17/07
Why is the Sinéad O'Connor interview on your website? I am a pastor of a church full of young adults. I am very happy with much of the post-modern stuff. I am happy for you to do an interview with Sinéad—but why just allow her to promote this rubbish without comment on what the Bible teaches about the gospel. She is clearly not a Christian, and is communicating non-gospel ideas. At least put in your own comments on how she differs from what the Bible and gospel teach. A [non-Christian] surfing the web might read this article … and think that Christianity teaches that there is more than one way to heaven. I am extremely concerned by this.
Mark Broadbent
posted 07/17/07
I perceive from Sinéad O'Connor by virtue of her answers and statements that she is a heathen and am surprised that you would bother to interview her and extend to her a sense of credibility.
Andy Kemperle
posted 07/17/07
While I do not feel Ms. O'Connor has a clear, biblical picture of who Jesus is, I at least did not find her comments to be shallow. I can't say the same for the disappointing line of questions presented to her. I expected more depth and compassionate "reaching out" from [Christian Music Today]. This is not the discussion she would have received from Jesus—or even Billy Graham.
Rachel Dean
posted 07/17/07
Greetings from Ireland. Quite coincidentally, I just returned from a concert with Sinéad O'Connor and the Irish Chamber Orchestra in Limerick. She played all her songs from Theology, and it was more the broken human spirit that came across than someone ever claiming to know it all—a very moving experience. I've just read the e-mail comments responding to your interview with her. It is sad that we Christians can get lost in our rightness without hearing the heart emanating from singers like Sinéad. I think your comment in your newsletter is spot on: "While an artist's music may be grounded in God's Word, it doesn't necessarily mean the artist is grounded in solid Christian theology." She is a voice in the wilderness, surrounded by intense religiosity, both Catholic and Protestant. It seems there's a segment of the church family that believes, "Get your theology right, get your life right, and then God will welcome you." Problem is, we may never!
Alasdair Verschoyle
posted 07/17/07
I for one respect your decision to interview O'Connor and publish her thoughts, leaving it up to us as readers to decide what to make of her. I've read some interviews with her on other sites as well, and she makes some valid and thoughtful points about religion versus faith. Truth can be found in many places, and I appreciate your willingness to highlight that through your Glimpses of God series and interviews like this one.
Dan Butcher
posted 07/17/07
I just want to say that I'm glad you interview artists about their beliefs. This is how we know where they are coming from, and knowing that, we believers can discern for ourselves. Reading Sinéad O'Connor's interview was so sad. She's completely missing the point! I don't understand how she can read the Bible and not understand that God is holy and perfect, not some energy that [allows everyone] to get to heaven someday. Reading the interview has helped me to realize that as a believer in Christ, I have a responsibility to tell people the truth. Maybe she's been told and doesn't care, but I will pray that she will keep reading the Bible and that the Holy Spirit will make things clear to her. Maybe Sinéad's decision to [reach out to Christian culture] is the way for her to come to know Christ as her one true Savior. Thank you for the article.
Mandy Davis
posted 07/17/07
Regarding the interview with Sinéad O'Connor, it seems to me the Christian community has the responsibility to be in prayer for her salvation. My prayer is that she will understand that "all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God," and that she understand hell is a real place—but that more importantly, so is heaven. Whatever she is wrestling with would be nailed to the cross. So, what do you think Christian community? Can we all pray in agreement?
Jane Fetsch
posted 07/10/07
Sinéad O'Connor doesn't have a clue about Christianity, and I am very disappointed you even spent time interviewing her for a Christian column. She sounds more New Age than anything. I am disgusted that you posted her comments. Shame on you!
Keri Pletka
posted 07/10/07
I don't think she has a clue about the God of Creation and his Son Jesus Christ. I believe she has created a god to suit her own opinion. That is called idolatry. I am not sure she has spent much time reading the Word. Not everyone is going to be saved. I struggle to see how anyone can read his Word and come up with her interpretation. Sounds like Sinéad is full of excuses of why she chooses to be disobedient to God.
Jacqui Jo Fahrnow
posted 07/10/07
Has someone taken the time out to tell Sinéad that Jesus is not made in her image and likeness? We are made in the image and likeness of the living God, not the other way around. The lack of reverence and synergistic familiarity some of these folks have about the things of God are going to land them in hell if they don't repent. And that would be a shame, because the Lord desires all to be saved. Somebody needs to tell them about the real Love of God, that as he saves us, he also chastises us out of that love.
Helen Thomas
posted 07/10/07
Any Christian who has any sensitivity to the teachings of Scripture will see immediately the mixed bag of O'Connor's "theology." She has a clear sense of how and why the Catholic priests and "hierarchy" erred morally in the sexual abuse scandals, and even of how they should have handled it. She understands God's love, but apparently not his wrath. She is a universalist who does not believe in the reality of sin and human depravity. To call Jesus an "energy" and equate him and the other members of the Trinity with Allah or Buddha is simply a rehash of the old, anti-Christian New Age movement. She does not see human beings as needing a Savior, nor does she see Jesus as that Savior. Yet God is still in the business of hitting home runs with crooked bats. And O'Connor's new album does draw heavily on Scripture, after all. We can hope and pray that some of the wisdom and truth of the OT will come through to most listeners. At the same time, we can only hope and pray that listeners will not be drawn to adopt her highly unscriptural "theology."
Rev. Tim Deibler
posted 07/10/07
What a waste of space. The interview was s---. Yes, that's right, I have no "qualms about swearing." Andree Farias seemed intent to be exclusive, wanting Sinéad to claim to be a North American evangelical Christian so that she could be told she wasn't meeting God's standard. Instead of building bridges, encouraging her to continue to seek after Jesus, it became the same heavy-handed garbage that is standard in western Christianity. I thought Christianity Today was beyond that tripe, but I guess not. Please don't let this crap happen again.
Joel Martin
To Compare or Not Compare?
posted 06/18/07
In response to your recent newsletter, I believe that comparisons are a very valuable tool for all of us. It helps me when I'm looking for music and is a great way to introduce someone to Christian music. As for the comments that it isn't Christian to do so, I just don't see it. We must meet people where they are, which isn't the same thing as condoning [sinful] lifestyles. Paul considered his audience all the time (e.g. the unknown god speech on Mars Hill in Acts 17), and Jesus himself used very "secular" images in his parables to convey deeper spiritual truths.
Brian Rihner
posted 06/18/07
I must admit our family is totally clueless as to who any secular bands are. We listen to local Christian stations for all our music. So as far as secular bands go, comparisons have no value to us since we really don't know any. Comparisons to other Christian bands are more worthwhile.
Dave Hawkins
posted 06/18/07
As a relatively new Christian, it's hard for me to decide what music to listen to. I am glad for the comparisons since I know what sound I like and can find artists in Christian music with your help.
Kathleen Knox
posted 06/18/07
Comparisons are great for new Christians who want to enjoy Christian music, but aren't familiar with the sound of the varying CCM artists. For those who complain, they should be reminded that everything has a healthy medium. After all, you can be too spiritual, and thereby creating stumbling blocks for others.
Chris Beville
posted 06/18/07
I've got to admit, I cringe anytime I see the byline "sounds like" in a music review. A musicians' works should stand on its own merit. However, people are always asking me about bands I like, and their first question is usually, "What do they sound like?" For people who don't have much in the way of mainstream music exposure, the "sounds like" byline is definitely a useful tool.
Zach Lorton
posted 06/18/07
Comparing Christian artists to mainstream artists helps me a lot. I used to listen to mainstream music, and when I decided to listen to Christian music to "feed my faith," I was looking for stuff that sounded similar to the music I was comfortable with. Although I must say now that I listen to Christian music, I prefer comparing Christian artists to other Christian artists rather than comparing them to sinners.
Didi Brown
posted 06/18/07
It never ceases to amaze me what people will complain about (and attempt to quote scripture about). I think comparisons in music reviews are crucial to quickly and efficiently communicating the sounds of an artist's album to the reader.
Linda DuBois
posted 06/18/07
I think that the reviewers at Christian Music Today are doing what they are called to do. They are providing a point of reference to show similarities (or differences) between the artist they are reviewing and an artist that we may already be familiar with. And they are doing it from an objective, third-party point of view.
Lewis Chatman
Happy Returns for All Star United
posted 06/18/07
Great review! I've always loved All Star United, so I can't wait to pick that one up. I've always thought Ian Eskelin would be a good friend in that he would fully understand the depths of whatever you're going through, but would be able to make you laugh at the same time.
Michael Ehret
Sola fide …
posted 04/26/07
Thank you for your in-depth, intelligent review of Neal Morse's latest project, Sola Scriptura. The fact that you're now covering him as a Glimpse of God makes this album even more interesting to me. Unlike Christianity Today, I believe the Bible suggests Christ is God—I don't believe it insists upon it. Fortunately, each person's walk with God is personal and individual, so my apparently "un-evangelical" beliefs are nobody's business but mine and God's. I live for an audience of One, not an audience of pastors and others all too ready to pass judgment. Either way, thanks for continuing to pay attention to Neal Morse. It's so refreshing to find prog rock in Christian music!
Frank King
The Other Side on The Otherly Opus
posted 04/26/07
Thank you for the well-written review of Joy Electric's The Otherly Opus. I am blown away by Ronnie Martin's work on The Otherly Opus. What I find most impressive about the album is the interesting songwriting. The layering of melodies, the arrangements of the vocal tracks, the stark production, all combine for an experience that leaves me simply floored. My argument is not that Joy Electric deserves admiration for being distinct when compared to other Christian artists—it is that Joy Electric deserves commendation for being excellent. I have found very few Christian artists who pursue [artistic] excellence instead of appealing to a wider crowd. It's this aspect that allows me to share Ronnie's music with my college mates, who desire music that's more leftfield and original.
Jonathan Avants
Moved by Doerksen
posted 04/16/07
I've just read the interview with Brian Doerksen and it is so powerful and so real. I used to work at a Christian radio station in Adelaide, Australia, and we often featured Brian's music. It's been incredibly refreshing to read about his journey with all its challenges, and to be left thinking about the faithfulness of God. I hope to forward a copy of the interview to the worship leaders at my local church so that they too can be encouraged by Brian's honesty and insight.
Doug Oakley
Idol Chatter
posted 03/26/07
I had to chuckle over your commentary about American Idol because we were just talking at my weekly Bible study about sharing one's faith, and how difficult it is for people who are so immersed in the culture of their church that they end up "preaching to the choir." For a Christian to share their faith, they must go out among "them." The Idol-like Christian shows are fine. But I would hope that the producers and supporters of these types of shows aren't intimating that these are the only types of shows we should watch or participate in as Christians. For once again, that would only be preaching to the choir.
Karlynn Anderson
posted 03/26/07
The idea of [American Idol] being able to glorify God made me laugh at the irony—something that so unashamedly proclaims "idol" in its name. While I believe an individual who participates in such an event could conceivably bring God glory in their act, the show as a whole will not. It is not centered on music as much as image. The show is rigged so only a certain kind of personality can even make it to the final round. Yes, you need a good voice, but if you don't have the certain "look," I guarantee you won't make it, regardless of how well you sing. For this reason, I don't believe the show will ever bring God glory. A few of the contestants may, but that will be as far as it goes. The subject of glorifying God is largely placed at the individual level. Each person has their own role to play and has to make their own decisions. We can never expect a secular show to do the job for us—it is our responsibility after all.
John Moser
posted 03/26/07
I do not believe we need an alternative to American Idol. Whether or not the show is Christian or not, if someone wants to idolize a singer, they will. Isn't Gifted just an exclusive [version of] Idol? It is still a singing competition, just like Idol—assuming of course that Gifted contestants aren't being judged by their level of Christianity.
Jess Yu
posted 03/26/07
It's sad that this Gifted/Idol dichotomy still exists in the Christian culture. The evangelical church still doesn't seem to get that we are called to be salt and light, and not "hidden under a bushel." The arts are one of the best ways to help people see their own humanity and need for grace. Christians should aim to bring a new level of quality to Idol, whether the lyrics express their faith explicitly or not. Being made in the image of God, any human is attesting to the glory of God by using their vocal gifts.
Jeff Yourison
posted 03/26/07
I'm strictly against Christians using their talents that God has given to them for a competition. If a certain Christian group wants to raise funds for a particular venture, they can come together and have a concert asking for donations to assist with [whatever the cause]. I don't think that God has given our talents to us for us to compete—it is like fighting. God has given us our talents to glorify his name … and to save souls. No one will get the message in a competition.
Elma Chapman
posted 03/26/07
It seems as though the majority of Christians today want to only socialize with other Christians, only listen to Christian music, and only watch programs that are Christian oriented. I believe it was Christ that said, "It is not the healthy who need the doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners (Mark 2:16-17)." With that scripture at the forefront of our life service, it seems only befitting for us to be in the world and not to hibernate in our [Christian culture].
Scott Adlon
posted 03/26/07
As far as Idol is concerned, I think the creation of a Christian based alternative was a knee jerk reaction—like, "Oops, we should've thought of this idea in the first place!" All too often, it seems the church reacts instead of pro-acts. While, I'm sure the people in the Gifted competition were [openly] thankful, it never gained the attention Idol has and never will. Idol is bringing in all walks of life … and it's so important that these Christian and non-Christian contestants meet and interact. There's a greater chance of the Great Commission being fulfilled. We need not be a closet performer anymore!
Karen Allenn-Chitwood
posted 03/26/07
I used to be a huge fan of American Idol, and felt great excitement when contestants would thank God or mention prayer as of way of dealing with the stress. However, the advertisements during Idol have become [increasingly counterproductive] to the "purity" that Idol is trying to provide. For example, every single episode has had an ad for Victoria's Secret. With both a teen son and preteen daughter watching, I have to scramble for the remote to turn the channel. As a Christian family, we do not watch Idol as often, and if we do, we have to sit with the remote in hand. It is disappointing that a show that has the potential to do good puts all morals aside for [advertising] money.
Rosi Crawford
posted 03/26/07
I've always wanted to become a [professional] singer, and I too tried out for American Idol, because my friends wanted me to. Walking with the Lord and having a goal to seek his will, we all know we should use our talents and skills to glorify his name. My dream is to sing and evangelize, but I guess we should always pray to him to use our talents because only he can decide.
Alesia Cruz
posted 03/26/07
I am a Christian vocal coach with my own studio. My students range from gifted 9-year-old to college-age and beyond. I have used Idol a lot in teaching my students about glorifying God with their voices and the music they choose to sing, whether that be an Italian aria or a Contemporary Christian pop song in a worship setting. I have a strong desire to see Christian artists move into the world, not to become like them, but to help impact God's plan for all creation by setting Christ-like examples through their music. People can still sing for the Lord while "performing" a piece. We need God's people to be integrated in programs like Idol.
Susie Amerise
posted 03/26/07
I think that what you may want to look at is how many of the participants in Idol have gone on to record Christian songs since appearing on the show. Many of them have taken their experience as an opportunity to record songs for the Lord and take the message of hope to others. I think it shows that once you show a child the way to love God, even when he is old he will keep God's way.
Eduardo De Jesus
posted 03/26/07
American Idol can definitely serve as a vessel for Christians to share Jesus. God created them with beautiful voices, energy, the ability to stand up to [scrutiny], and the Lord knows what else! May they all stop cowering behind the makeup mirrors, tattoo parlors, fashion studios, pharmacy counters, jewelry bins, and start doing what the Lord Jesus created them to do.
Elizabeth Good
Some Words from Christian Radio
posted 01/22/07
Your article concerning Christian radio makes some assumptions I feel are unfounded. I have been involved in Christian music radio since 1976. You assume that all "Christian" radio stations are the same, that we all are called to evangelize and represent the diversity of Christianity. We are not. All individual Christians are called to the Great Commission, but not all business enterprises. Some of our stations are committed to providing information and entertainment to those who feel comfortable with the Christian lifestyle, but are not involved in the evangelical efforts of the church. Perhaps a good question to ask is, "Why are these radio stations approaching their business in this fashion?" Perhaps the answer is these Christian radio stations are experiencing success in ways the industry has never enjoyed. Success in this sense means more people are listening to Christian radio than at any time in measurable history.
Gary Walsh
Editor's note: Neither the article itself nor its author is making any such "assumptions" about Christian radio. Shaun Groves, a Christian artist, was quoted as saying that many Christian radio stations think of themselves as "evangelistic" when they're really just serving a Christian audience.
posted 01/22/07
As one who works in Christian radio, I find Geil's series to be a revealing glimpse inside the workings of Christian radio today. It's not exhaustive, and I wish there were more responses from radio programmers and managers. But it does highlight the landscape and dynamics that dictate much of Christian radio's structure and operations. Sometimes exploring the inner workings of a familiar medium raises more questions than it answers. That's good. Any constructive dialogue between radio and listeners will help us strengthen what we do.
Cecil Van Houten
Complaints from "Becky"
posted 01/22/07
As a 41-year-old woman, I'm disturbed that "they" think AC radio is the music I want to hear most. The 35-44-year-old group today grew up on rock 'n' roll. I like soft rock, but I like heavy metal too. What I want from my CCM is talent and great meaningful lyrics. I don't want pop/churchy music. I despise the drivel I hear on my local radio station. I know there are groups playing what I want, but now that I'm not at a Christian college, I have problems finding them. My tastes didn't change when I turned 30.
Leila Pitchford-English
posted 01/22/07
I am a 40-something mom who is very concerned that there's nothing out there on the radio for kids to listen to. Christian radio indeed targets the "soccer moms and dads"— even though I personally prefer Project 86, Disciple, or Underoath to Point of Grace. Our youth need to listen to the kind of music they want to hear with lyrics that aren't profane, immoral, or violent. We have so many excellent Christian artists who never get airtime because Christian radio is not playing their kind of music. Even if Christian radio would dedicate certain times of the day to music that our youth would enjoy (e.g. before and after school, weekends) it would be helpful. I truly feel like there's a huge ministry opportunity we're missing because we don't offer kids the Christian alternatives (available right now) to the secular music that they are listening to.
Christine A. Hill
posted 01/22/07
It sure explains why I like Christian radio when I was in the "Becky" age group and raising my kids. But now it seems bouncy, irrelevant, and plain annoying. I'd love to hear some of the alternative music my kids listen to, but some of the fringe stuff I can only check out by borrowing from our students!
Rosemarie Kowalski
Just a Phase for Lennon
posted 01/22/07
I read the excerpt from The Gospel According to the Beatles. What's next? The Gospel According to Ozzy? The New Testament according to Marilyn Manson? John Lennon's "Christian phase" means nothing to me and it shouldn't mean a hill of beans to any other of your readers. Unless, of course, Christianity Today is trying to be "of the world" and drop names to get more readership. It makes me upset sometimes for Christian entities (magazines, TV stations, websites, etc.) to pull the world into what they are putting out there.
Jeffery Guill
Editor's note: Mr. Guill is apparently in the minority. The book excerpt about John Lennon's "born-again phase" has been of huge interest to readers, rating as one of the most highly-read Christianity Today articles in months. The article doesn't "legitimize" Lennon's phase, but merely reports what the former Beatle apparently experienced. As for the Gospel According to Ozzy, if he came to Christ, or even just had a "Christian phase," you bet we'd report it.
Thank God for the Glimpses
posted 01/22/07
Thank you for your Glimpses of God section. For a while now, I've been getting sick of the same Christian music. Lately some of the sounds have been similar to the taste of saccharine—sweet at first, then eww. Because of your Glimpses, I have been able to find much more of a connection with the Lord through music [outside the box]. The best example was your article on India.Arie. I purchased her album the same day I read it—three months later, I'm still grooving to her music. Another was Scott Stapp. [Editor's note: Stapp's review wasn't a "Glimpse," but close enough!] Unfortunately, we all stumble and fall, but two of his songs on his solo album really picked me up during a "desert" season. Thank you so much! Please continue letting God use this for his glory!
B. Warren
Helping the Little Guy
posted 01/15/07
Thank you very much for including us, Runway 36, in your Indie Artist Spotlight. We can tell you really listened and got into the music. We have since received many comments from new fans that found us because of your site. Thanks again for helping us out, and for listening to our little Minnesota band.
Michael Allen
Editor's note: Click here to find information on independent artist submissions.
Apologetics for Apologetix
posted 01/15/07
I feel the review of Apologetix's WordPlay misses the mark on several points. My teenagers don't care if they "know" the original songs. They love the music for what it is. In fact, they're really irritated if I slip up and start singing the original words. Yes, I've sometimes wished that Apologetix pushed the "humor" aspect of their songs a bit more, but then again, I am already "saved." I recognize a huge part of their outreach is evangelism. If I have to give up a laugh during a song for a more God-centered lyric, that's okay. Besides, if you look at their work as a whole, there is plenty of humor and fun. Just attend one of their concerts and you'll be hooked for life. I'd rank WordPlay as one of the top CDs of 2006.
Eric Huffman
posted 01/15/07
As a mom of four, I believe that the appeal of Apologetix to a broad audience is part of the excitement. My husband is a fan of classic rock that became a believer in his early twenties, so he had many years to acquire a taste for that style of music played well. I grew up with little exposure to pop. Our kids really only listen to Christian music. And we all love Apologetix. The kids like the energy of the music, but don't have to have any familiarity with the often detestable original lyrics. It's great to have a group that parents and kids can all enjoy going to see in concert, who take the time to write clever and God-honoring lyrics. Also, we love the Scripture references in the songs.
Terri Sweetland
posted 01/15/07
I became a Christian in 1982 as a 12-year-old and slowly transitioned away from secular music. I really loved listening to songs such as "Wanted Dead or Alive" by Bon Jovi, and I missed them when I left them behind. Suddenly I find the song has been redeemed. I can listen to the tune I always loved with words that inspire, and/or words that keep my mind on things of above. [As far as the target audience being too broad or unspecific], why does one have to narrow the market? Every song on every CD may not hit the mark with every listener. But which CDs ever hit the mark with each and every song? Instead of questioning their tactics and use of parody, shouldn't you just be thankful they are reaching such a wide variety of people. God does work through them; hopefully that is enough.
Jodi Ash
posted 01/15/07
Mr. Breimeier's review lists a number of his personal problems with the band. I don't think there is a "target" audience, and if he would attend any of their concerts, he would see everyone from grandkids to grandparents all having a good time. Most Apologetix CDs have at least twenty songs, so even if you only like half of them you still have a normal CD's worth of songs you like. You do not have to be familiar with the original songs to like the remakes. I have never heard of most of the original songs on Wordplay, but I like every song on the CD. I'll even crank up "Bone Digger" and I don't like rap. This is what makes Apologetix so awesome. They really do appeal to a large audience for a lot of different reasons. And although Apologetix is a parody band, they are not just a parody band. They are a Christian band with a message, and using parodies to deliver it. Mr. Breimeier doesn't seem to understand that they are not Weird Al. I think Mr. Breimeier should stop trying to figure them out, and just enjoy the music.
Wess Eslinger
Honesty the Best Policy
posted 01/15/07
As a regular reader of your newsletters, I appreciate your genuine and honest approach to Christian music. I also think it's great that you expect quality from Christian musicians and review based on the quality of an album, without major biases due to musical genre, past albums by the artist, etc. I have discovered many incredible artists through your newsletter and continue to be inspired by them, and even when I disagree with your reviews, I can tell that you are offering an honest assessment and you always support your views very well. But most of all, I enjoy reading your introduction in each newsletter. I love that you address such a wide variety of issues, which you connect back to Christian music, but also apply to many areas of life. There have been many times that I've been encouraged, challenged, and inspired by the insights you offer. Thank you for sharing your thoughts so openly. I pray that you'll know you are appreciated, be encouraged, and keep up the good work!
Angela Smith
posted 01/15/07
The insightful stuff you guys are writing and sharing is really one of the highlights of my week here in Stockholm, Sweden. Even on the days that I don't have time to read it all, I only have to sift through a few lines until a smile breaks forth. As one who's educated in both TV and radio, I'm so glad you have the guts to bring up some of the toughest topics—both the pluses and the minuses of the music business. As for those who are quick to label you "unchristian" for being disappointed with an album, that's about the most immature thing I've heard in a long time. Everyone ought to know by now that a review is a review, not an eternal truth. And if you are a true fan, why should you let a single review become a personal blow? Jesus didn't respond to his [detractors] by getting back at them or passing out irrevocable judgments. God has given us common sense, so let's use it. Honesty and vulnerability go a long way in speaking to the men and women of this world.
Åsa Gustafsson
posted 01/15/07
As a worship music director, I share your feelings regarding the criticism of Christian music. I read the reviews from various Christian music sources, [and similarly,] I hear what members of the congregation unabashedly tell me what they think of my music choices. It all has to be taken with a large grain of salt. There will never be agreement amongst Christians regarding music. Diverse taste in music is typical in most churches, and the only problem is that most people are not willing to recognize and respect that diversity. I harbor the hope that Christians will become educated in the principle that it is our identity in Christ that unites us, not our common tastes.
Brigit Parlow
Best Albums for the Best-Of List?
posted 12/11/06
I'd previously written you an email saying that there wasn't any good music or bands out there anymore, and that Christian Music had lost it's "spark" since the early 80's. Well, I'm glad to [read] your list of the Best Christian Albums of 2006. It actually blew me away—I need to get out more! This was an "ear-opening" experience for me and you guys are right on. Thanks for the great work. I've gotta stop skipping through your email and listen to what's out there. Very, very impressed!
Paul Steven
Could someone please explain to me what I'm missing with Jars of Clay's Good Monsters? Both Christian Music Today and CCM magazine picked it as best album of the year, but I was very disappointed with it after listening to it. I had heard "Carry Me" and the title track from the album on the band's MySpace page, and was excited about what I heard. It sounded like Jars of Clay was going in a new, edgier direction. What I heard on the rest of the album was music that would, in my opinion, fit well on any country music station. I don't buy CDs to get only 2 good songs from it. All the songs should be up to par; in the end, Good Monsters just didn't impress me. But kudos to Andy Argyrakis for including Skillet's Comatose as [an honorable mention]. I'm not a "Panhead" by any means, but it's an excellent album from start to finish.
Michele Schroeder
I am really glad to see Derek Webb in the top picks. I've seen little mentioned about this excellent album in 2006, other than lots of people downloading it for free. And I loved to see Jars of Clay at #1—clearly the best album of the year and possibly this decade.
Robert Blake
I just finished scrolling and reading slowly down the list of best albums, complete with imaginary drum rolls and envelope tearing sounds. Tears formed in my eyes with outbursts of laughter as album after album were by bands that I've tagged in my collection as potentially great artists whose work I'll still be listening to decades from now. Of course, I may not agree completely with every album on the final list, but I do have tremendous respect for it and will revisit a few that wouldn't have made my list to see what I missed. Thanks again & know that you've been a great encouragement to someone who's run the gamut from trashing all my "secular" music in high school and listening exclusively to [CCM], to developing a deep love and appreciation for all kinds of music.
Jay Conder
Taking a Stand
posted 11/20/06
I can imagine the review of Michael W. Smith's new CD was tough to write, but as I listened to it, I agreed with everything you said—it just doesn't measure up. When you write and record an album in 40 days, you have microwaved the music instead of allowing it to simmer over time. I guess what baffles me is that Smitty's best material was usually written with Wayke Kirkpatrick. Why doesn't he include more collaboration with Wayne these days? But as you said, hopefully his next project will regain some lost ground. I think a lot of people would love for him to return to a more acoustic sound and plain 'ol good songwriting.
Kent Sanders
I was really glad when I read about how you gave Smith's newest only two stars. No, I don't mean I'm glad you rated it low, but I'm glad that like you said, if we "believe an album falls short, we have to say so—even if we're fans of the artist—and we have to do so with grace and honesty." I really appreciate that honesty, especially in our Christian culture where everyone is supposed to "be nice and not judge."
Mary Ruth
I agree that Stand falls far short compared to Smitty's earlier albums. But is it possible that his latest albums, alongside Worship and Healing Rain, are in a completely different genre of Christian music? I think most artists establish themselves in a particular genre with their earlier works, but then they have the right to dabble in other genres over time. In Smitty's case, his recent efforts give him a solid body of work in the worship genre.
Debbie Lockledge
Stand falls short of Michael's capacity, but as I said to my friends here in France, sometimes it is better to fall short once and then come back with a bang. I believe with all my heart that Michael will come back with a stronger album.
Faith Benson
Defending the Flood
posted 11/20/06
Usually I think your reviews are pretty spot on, but not in the case of the new Sonicflood record. I completely disagree that Glimpse sounds like "note for note studio output." Has the reviewer ever listened to a Sonicflood record? Way more energy on this one [than the typical] CCM live record. I'm sorry a significant and powerful Christian publication seems to have just missed this.
Dave Howard
Editor's note: We often get letters that disagree with our reviews, and that's fine. But to ask, "Has the reviewer ever listened to such-and-such" is disingenuous. We can only say, "Duh. Of course."
Reservations for Robert Randolph
posted 11/20/06
In your interview with Robert Randolph, I feel you should have followed up on his reply that Scripture is able to say "anything." That's a false belief that many Christians have today, and reveals a clear lack of logic [in Randolph's thinking]. His attitude that he's not the "biggest Scripture reader" should also make us look at his music more critically. If you are sending a message musically in the name of the Lord, shouldn't your foundation of music be sound?
Mark Murphy
Do Greatest Hits albums still matter today?
posted 08/07/06
Thank you for raising this issue. I completely agree that "Greatest Hits" recordings used to mean something, but now I don't get them unless it's an artist I wouldn't otherwise buy. My criticism has to do with how labels have decided to add one or two new songs that you couldn't get otherwise. Of course, it had the intended effect—I would fork over the $16.98 for the new "single" from an artist I particularly liked, even though I already had the other 8-10 songs from the original albums. I find the blatant and crass commercialism of it offensive. Some labels won't even permit those new songs to be downloaded "without the purchase of the entire album," in which case I simply forego those songs in protest of the label.
David Neal
What I really hate about Greatest Hits albums these days is that they put them out while adding 1-3 new songs to it, thus almost forcing a rabid fan to spend extra money to buy a whole album for a few tracks. That is just greedy and wrong to me. An example of a band that was "greatest hitted" to death was White Heart. They [seemed to have] six Best Of albums with three different record labels. I also have to laugh when an artist (like Plumb) has a greatest hits collection after just two albums—clearly pure profit for the record company.
Lee Snyder
I buy Hits albums all the time. Not only do I get to listen to my personal favorites, but it's also a great way to discover artists that I am not familiar with. It doesn't matter what label the artists are on if they are singing for God.
Rosemary Neeley
I think the concept of a Greatest Hits album has definitely changed in the 21st century. We're now in an age of downloads, iPods, and playlists, so the end consumer can create their own "greatest hits" segment of songs with a few clicks. I noticed a recent Mark Knopfler compilation for sale, and while scanning the song titles, I couldn't help but think that it looked nearly identical to a mix CD I had already created from all of his CD's in my collection. I think that in another age, it was a brilliant idea, but the "event" factor for a Greatest Hits package is certainly lessened in this day and digital age.
Brack Haynes
I think it is a great way to introduce new Christians to music that was available before they came to know Christ. In a way, I suppose it helps keep the artist in the mind of the public—secular musicians have always done this. I really appreciate these offerings because you can usually get the great songs all on one CD.
Nora Parsons
I don't think Hits or Best Of compilations are as popular as they used to be. They are a nice way for one to get a great selection of music from an artist with whom they've just recently become familiar. That way they know their getting what most fans consider the good stuff. But I think you pegged it when you said the Internet has changed that. For anyone who is already familiar with an artist, you can easily build a Hits collection from digital downloads. And I also agree that some of the things that went into a special Hits collection of music have waned. It used to be tremendous fun to see a collection of photographs on the inside [such an album]—pouring through the credits to see who played on the songs, reading stories about why they were written, and what lasting impact the artist would have on music. In the future, I wouldn't be surprised if we saw less and less of these compilations—because of individual tastes, because of the growth of Internet sales, and because there are simply fewer artists these days producing enough great music to justify a Hits collection.
Brian Adamson
Fixing CCM
posted 07/24/06
That was some great insight by Mark Joseph in his article, "How to Fix CCM." It's sad that these labels would want to be "separate" from the world even though they're [almost] all owned by secular companies. The bottom line though is that if your music is good, people will notice regardless of a Christian message. It's about time for the dividing line to be erased, and we're finally beginning to see more than positive messages of hope for the church.
Wally Olesek
I do believe that once a person accepts Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior that their life will change for the better.The earlier article about Muth Math suing their record company made them sound as if they were ashamed to be Christians or associated with them. There are a couple of Christian bands that have successfully crossed over to mainstream music, and there's nothing wrong with that. But what's wrong with reflecting who you are to people who aren't as interested in Jesus? Isn't that what being a Christian is all about?
Marsha A. Perales
Amen to that entire commentary. It's about time someone really took a stand against this Christian subculture we have created. We are called by Christ to be in the world, to be lights for Christ in dark places. We cannot do that if we are constantly running away from the people we are supposed to try to reach. Tooth & Nail Records does this by marketing their music everywhere, even though many of the bands on the label are "Christian" bands. The success of bands such as Emery, Underoath, Anberlin, and even P.O.D. shows that it works and it gets the message of Christ out there. What more of a witness can a band have than when they play an awesome show, then share the gospel with a kid back at their merchandise table?
Mark Phillips
Mark Joseph has some good points in his article, but misses others that are pretty important.Joseph's assertion of "when the listeners enjoy the music, itwill translate to active listeners and buyers" misses out on many other factorsleading tosuccess. Not the least of which is the human condition, and how it reacts to the searing light of truth that comes from more "overtly Christian" lyrics that aren'topen to interpretation.Sin, the exclusiveness of Jesus, and the call to give up your rights are subjects that are not going to be [commonly] accepted in mainstream mass media. Many artists who are Christians will continue to see mass acceptance of their music despite (or evenbecause of) the "spiritual" content of their lyrics if it's a good listen.But I think it's naive to think that even catchy, creative, and captivating music will be widely accepted when it is accompanied by words that convict the listener.Most of us don't like to be challenged, and even those of us who do have comfort levels.There aren't too many people willing to shell out [money] to listen to a song that goes against their worldview.
Mike Hawver
The issue of how CCM should be marketed is a long running debate. At a 2002 GMA Week seminar, a vote was taken about P.O.D. and their mission to reach the un-churched by not being labeled a "Christian band." Most voted nearly 50-50 that the band needed to choose a label, one way or another. I was rather shocked; I had thought the crossover controversy had died out long ago. I remember the hits taken against Amy Grant, Michael W. Smith, and others when they became crossover artists in the '80s and '90s. But Christian industries (and even churches) are slow to change. The difficulty lies in knowing when to stop beating a dead horse, and adopting a new horse to get the job done. Over the course of the history of Christianity, different methods have had to be adapted to reach the non-believer. If shedding the label of "Christian artist" is what it takes to reach a non-Christian audience, then it's the mission of the artist to use that "adopted horse" to convey their message of faith—subtle or loudly—while living their life for Christ.
LM Oughterson
Joseph writes: "Imagine what would happen if Christian-oriented labels announced that they would change the way they do business—that for the artists who wanted to reach the mainstream, the labels would stop marketing them as 'Christian music,' and instead develop and market artists who write songs that reference their faith to fellow believers, as well as to millions of Americans who may not share their faith but like their music." One such label does exist: Illect Recordings. Hip hop is the "black sheep" of CCM, but there are true underground hip hop artists, such as those on the Illect label, that are really making inroads into the secular market.
David Yum
I've always wondered how someone who truly wanted to take the gospel to those who didn't already have it were planning to do so through the existing Christian music infrastructure. I believe that Christian artists cannot separate themselves from secular music if they want to have an evangelistic impact. Perhaps evangelism through music will have a chance after all if bands like Mute Math and Switchfoot can be models—well, maybe except for Mute Math's lawsuit.
Shane Longtin
Every artist has the free will to write and perform music that they choose. It sorrows me that some are perusing riches on earth instead of reaching for that future prize. That being said, everyone who confesses Jesus Christ as Lord has a command "Go into all the world and preach the good news to all creation" (Mark 16:15). What we don't see are their lives off stage. How do they conduct themselves among their family, peers, at the release parties, sitting with a fan backstage? Given the opportunity, do they share the Good News? We cannot see the heart, but God can. So let each artist select their lyrics—their lifestyle—and let God work on their heart "both to will and to do of his good pleasure."
Frank Dugie
Defining "Christian Artists"
posted 07/24/06
I don't think it's wrong for bands to try to appeal to the secular music industry. Like The Fray stated in your interview, they have a calling, and we have to trust that. I lived the majority of my life as a non-believer. It was Creed's lyrics that led me to Christ, although I didn't know it at the time. The searching to understand their lyrics led me on a search for Christ. If Creed's songs weren't played on the secular radio stations, I wouldn't know the Lord.
Paula Miller
"Bless the Broken Road" by Rascall Flatts, "I Believe" by Brooks and Dunn, "Jesus Take the Wheel" by Carrie Underwood, "Some People Change" by Montgomery Gentry"—these are all examples of Christian songs, but are they by "Christian artists?" Yes for several of them, but many others I don't know. They're not on Christian labels or Christian radio, but trying to label songs and artists by grouping them in "formats" is something secular programmers do to try and find commonalities for the sake of listeners. You ask a very tough question—I sure don't know the answer, but I do enjoy your asking it.
Dave Nicholson
Director of Country Operations
ABC Radio Networks Dallas
We're facing a similar issue with Catholic artists. Although the quality of the artists in Catholic music are not nearly at the standards of the CCM industry today, several are pioneering this change: Sarah Hart, Matt Maher, Joe Hand, Cheer Up Charlie, Marie Miller, Greg Walton, even Ceili Rain. Yet no one in the established Christian market wants to give these artists a platform for their music to be heard. Why? Because they believe in the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Church? I see so many Catholic artists who live faithful lives to serve Jesus Christ as their personal Savior, their lyrics are overtly Christian, and they certainly minister outside of their music. But they never get a shot to be featured on Christian radio, or have their product offered in Christian bookstores, or be considered as media worthy by the traditional CCM market. So they are forced to stay in the market now designated as "The Catholic Market," which includes very few opportunities—yet in the U.S. alone there are 60 million Catholics!
Alyson Bleistine
Danielson's Ships come in
posted 07/24/06
I am in possession of the only "listenable" CD—that I know of—by the Danielson Famile.It's called Fetch the Compass, Kids! Brilliant and "difficult to listen to" are understatements, but it is so encouraging to see that we Christians can be as wildly creative as the rest of the world. Thank you for such a glowing report on such cutting edge Christian music!
Laurence Miller
Defending Crunk Rock
posted 07/24/06
The review of Family Force 5's debut album was inane, typical CCM nonsense and completely undeserving. This is one of the better CDs out today, full of humor, good clean/Christian fun, and a much better alternative than what most Christian bands offer. The comparisons that were made to FF5 and some other secular artists were not very well thought out.Not a good review at all. These guys are reaching people for Jesus and that's all that matters.
Brandon Abney
Family Force 5 has the potential to reach farther from the Christian music comfort zone than any band I can think of. As you said, they are entertaining and you don't have to be Christian to listen to them. But if you listen to them you will find that they are Christian. That's the nice thing about it. Missionaries reach out to places where Christ is needed, but I see many Christian artists reaching out to just Christians. I see this band portraying the fishers of men analogy; now they are casting their nets out as far as possible. Through their example, you can look for their non-Christian audience to be pulled in. I'm all for deep, meaningful lyrics, but if you look close enough, this band has a purpose.
M. Braft
A New Dawn for Andrew Osenga
posted 07/17/06
Editor's note: Andrew Osenga and his closest friends—including his family—apparently liked our 5-star review of his latest album, The Morning. Some of their comments:
I want to express my greatest appreciation for such a wonderful review of a musician I've enjoyed for a long time. Andrew Osenga's songs have long been ones to enjoy for their grand musical quality as well as a welcoming solace in a time of generic pietism in [Christian music]. Andy's music has been a healer to my soul many times, and I love his music, his art, his love of life, his love of his family, and most of all, his love for our God.
Joey Carter
I thought I was done buying CDs for a while and now you have to go and give Andrew Osenga 5 stars—great … thanks … lol. A 5-star review means I'd be a fool to not order it.
Wally Olesek
Thanks for your great review of The Morning. It is encouraging to hear him and the other members of the Square Peg Alliance making good music and to read thoughtful coverage of their albums.
Caroline Kimbrough
Thank you so much for that article! As Andy's parents, we have recognized for years that he has a special gift from God.It is nice to see that others recognize it and are able to say it so well. It is also very encouraging to read your understanding of his style, musicality, production abilities, and his heart. We keep praying that God will work in and through Andy to bring glory to himself.
Dave and Donna Osenga
The Bell's Still Ringin'
posted 06/13/06
Thank you, thank you, thank you for the article "The Bell Tolls." I help lead a service for people in their 20s & 30s in our church and am having an impossible time finding music right now. Didn't know if it was just me. I walk in and out of our local Christian bookstore without finding anything that is either lyrically resonating or that catches me musically. And when I find one, it is generally without the other! Thanks for drawing attention to our need for deep, artistic, and truthful worship music.
Jenny Matthes
posted 06/13/06
I think the problem with much Christian music today is the same problem facing most (all?) pop music today: it's pablum. Pop music (and I'm including pop Christian music here) today is boring, repetitive, insomnia-curing; the lyrics tend to be uninspired and repetitive, too. The artists all sound the same. That's why I prefer the old-time gospel/country gospel/"Black" gospel/"Negro" spirituals of yesteryear. That kind of music includes a hunger for the Lord and passionately reflects that love, gratitude, worship for him; these "old" songs do that in a way that most pop music today doesn't. What Christian artists need to do, I think, is not branch out into the boring world of pap, uh, pop music, but reach into their passion for the Savior and convey that passion afresh to their listeners who thirst for music that touches the soul.
Sherry Soobotin
posted 06/13/06
In response to the article on Steve Bell: I am a pastor who has played guitar for the past 17 years. When it comes to songs for a radio station or CD, I agree that it's great to be as "artsy" as possible. But when it comes to worship music, as a pastor I consider that art should be secondary to facilitating worship. Worship music is like a language: we can try to re-create the past (perhaps using Latin) or we can seek to speak in the popular language of the day in order to communicate with as many people as possible. A church could hire the best, most artistically creative pipe organ player and opera singer; but no matter how good they are, it would sink most churches faster than the Titanic, simply because that language is far less popular. Inside the church, our "likes" need to take a back seat to the musical language(s) that have the widest appeal. Our assessment of its artistic value is not worth any more than the assessment of those who hunted down Tyndale, simply because they thought English vulgar. You can try to fight it, but personally I side with Tyndale! I am not a proponent of an art form; I am a proponent of the gospel. Music cannot transform a life and save a soul. As a 35-year-old musician, and someone who likes books from antiquity, I agree that it would be nice if people preferred our music over that of 17-year-olds. However, instead of being Sauls resenting the Davids of our time, let's pass the torch rather than waiting until we are so old that there is no one to pass it to! May we try to help them; mentor them; and facilitate their ministries. Let's rejoice that Delirious broke open the doors of worship in a language that an entire generation could appreciate! I am thankful that gifted musicians such as Martin Smith have generally tried to keep their worship songs simple, so that the others can use them on Sundays without having to practice for five years. I wish all worship writers would recognize that it doesn't have to be difficult to be brilliant.
Cory Schmidtz
An Honest Review
posted 06/13/06
Thank you for such an honest and straightfoward review on Krystal Meyers. This is the first Christian music review that I have ever read that addresses the fact that Christian artists (not just secular artists) follow generic song topics and formulas. I have noticed for years that some artists just simply aren't as spiritually deep as others, and their lyrics lack deeper insight or wisdom past the generic "God loves me, I love him, I surrender" themes that are so prevalent in lighter artists. I agree that Krystal's CD delivers what it promised: a cool-sounding rock chick delivering radio-listener-friendly music that entertains but doesn't challenge. Pointing out the artists who do "delve into relevant teen issues" like BarlowGirl and Superchick shows that it is not mutually exclusive to create great music that appeals to everyone while sharing a deeper part of God's truths. Thanks for a surprisingly insightful review. You were objective, concise, and refreshingly refrained from negative comments in this excellent review of a somewhat simple yet entertaining debut.
Jeremy Doran
Nash-tastic!
posted 06/05/06
Thanks for doing such a good job at Christian Music Today. Your interview with Leigh Nash was fantastic. She is such a unique and creative talent, and you had just the right questions to bring those qualities out. I had been wondering what she was up to since Sixpence ended, and I'm excited to hear her new stuff. I also appreciate all your hard work and insight with the interviews and reviews. It's nice to find some Christian music reviewers that aren't afraid to say an album is not good art, despite the intent to glorify God. Keep up the good work!
Troy Emenecker
Good Christians vs. Good Music
posted 02/06/06
Thank you for your words of discernment and faithfulness regarding musical response to faith. As a church musician, I find myself occasionally confronted with individuals that feel that our effort is only what is important and that the quality of our musical performance is not important—only the presence of the Spirit and the genuineness of our faith. I agree that the presence of the Holy Spirit and our faithfulness are vital, but as musicians, we are entrusted with a unique gift of expression. When we use this gift of music, it must never intrude on or distract from the message. When the performance is poor (or worse), that is what will [ultimately] receive the attention. Good Christian music, whether for listening or worship, must be transparent enough to allow the Spirit and message to get through.
Steve Wood
posted 02/06/06
What constitutes good music depends on the person you are talking to. There are many mediocre talents who have had great success due to marketing and PR, and there are many great talents that get overlooked because of lack of marketing and PR. The most important thing is for a Christian artist to do what God tells him to do—if making music is what God tells him to do, then that is nobody else's business to refute that.
Deborah Reece
posted 02/06/06
Regarding people who equate faith with talent, I can't help but think of the American Idol auditions. So many of the contestants have such sincere desire ("Music is my LIFE!") and sing with such earnestness, but they can't carry a tune to save their lives! I commend you for boldly stating that not all Christians make great music. My husband and I listen to all kinds of music from hard rock to jazz, but when we it comes to Christian music, it's very hard to find the same diversity and talent. We wade through a lot of generic pop that all sounds the same—no matter how sincere the heart of the artist!
Laura McBride
Stand-ing Up for Avalon
posted 02/06/06
I fully disagree with your review of Avalon's Stand. Yes, they are changing their style, but at least they can pull it off. The lyrics are fine. Some of these songs are just what people need to hear. The real point of Christian music is for the artist to minister to the public through song. That is exactly what Avalon is doing. Just because a song doesn't have the deepest lyrics in the world doesn't render it useless. Christian music doesn't have to fit critics' standards for God to work through it. Keep an open mind.
Lisa Tober
posted 02/06/06
Regarding your review of Stand: I couldn't agree more. I mean what were they thinking? You are totally right about the song "Jesus"—the whole idea of this Holy One who took my sin, shed his blood and rose again is a totally washed up message. And you're right: We need to quit saying "God is love" in Christian songs today and instead talk about all the misery that Christians go through in their walk with Christ. Avalon is just too happy all the time, don't you agree?
Ben Greene
Editor's note: No, sarcasm is definitely not lost on us.
For Those Who Have Ears …
posted 01/16/06
I recently discovered your excellent Glimpses of God column and would like to thank you for your careful and prayerful consideration of the artists and songs featured. I started my own Live365 internet radio station almost two years ago along these lines, playing songs by mainsteam artists that lyrically lean toward God and heaven. I am amazed at discovering new finds almost daily! I have been using your column and its archives to update my own playlist, and it's been a true blessing.
Peter Liam Holcross
T-Bone Blinded by Bling?
posted 01/16/06
I was highly interested in your interview with Christian hip-hop artist T-Bone. I am highly supportive of hip-hop music as a ministry, and I have heard many artists who have served Christ powerfully through it. [However], I think T-Bone is doing a terrible job. It's not that he lacks skill, but because of his blatantly hypocritical life. Despite the fact that he wants to rap for God, T-Bone dishonors his Lord by promoting the materialism and pride of secular hip-hop. We all know that the hip-hop genre of the world is polluted with violence, sexual immorality, and shady living, but we also need to realize that bling and egotism are just as bad. When T-Bone boasts of his wealth and rapping skill, he is sinning against God through pride. I think God could use him more if he were willing to sacrifice his ego and his materialistic spirit.
Andy_Rew
Not Nice to Diss the Audience
posted 01/16/06
4th Avenue Jones may have a cool style, but they slammed the audience hard at 2005's Spirit West Coast. Apparently we "sucked," and when we finally cheered enough to win back their approval, they rocked out to a Nirvana song. People in the Word look to Christian artists for motivation and hope, not to be told that they suck.
Jeannie Borbe
Mixed Reactions to Post-Christmas Releases
In a recent newsletter, we asked if you rushed out right after Christmas to buy new albums. Here are some replies.
posted 01/16/06
I did buy FFH's new release the week it came out, but with all the new music I had received for Christmas, I wasn't in a terrible rush to pick up new music. If it hadn't been for a gift card, I wouldn't have bought FFH's album. Record labels would do much better if they released these albums before the holidays [so I could ask for them for Christmas]. I was shocked when I saw the number of CDs being released two days after Christmas!
Jeffrey Thomas
posted 01/16/06
I did not rush out to buy new Christian Music. I'm more interested in knowing which of the labels are picking up on the trend to go straight to the Internet with their projects, bypassing the normal brick and mortar channels altogether. That's definitely the wave of the future.
Roger A. Dills
posted 01/16/06
I'm a music freak, so I always try to buy a new release the day it drops. December 27 was no exception—I went on a rabid search for the new Derek Webb CD. I would have picked it up on its release day no matter what time of year!
Bill Newton
posted 01/16/06
Marketers need to understand that most buyers are exhausted after the holidays, and that we tend to cut back on spending after Christmas. After all, most of us have overspent their budgets by that point.
Bill Jarocki
Protest and Praises
posted 01/16/06
I couldn't help but notice that your album reviewer(s) thinks that absolutely nothing sounds good—sp |
